"Should we be running Performance Max?" is one of the most common questions we hear from South African business owners, usually right after an agency or a Google rep has suggested it. The honest answer is that it is the wrong way to frame the choice. Performance Max and Search do different jobs, and Google itself says Performance Max is meant to complement keyword-based Search campaigns, not replace them. Here is how to decide what your account actually needs.
Two Campaign Types, Two Different Jobs
A Search campaign shows text ads when someone types a query that matches the keywords you chose. You decide the queries, write the ads and see exactly which searches triggered them. It is precise, which is why it is the backbone of most lead generation accounts.
A Performance Max campaign works the other way round. You give Google a goal, a budget, creative assets and some audience signals, and its automation decides where to show your ads. Placements can include Search, Shopping, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail and Maps. You trade control for reach and for Google's ability to find converters you would not have targeted by hand.
in Search
in Performance Max
accounts
The question is not which one wins. It is which one gets which job.
Anaye Digital Paid Search TeamThe Real Risk: Paying Twice for Your Own Brand
The most common problem we see is Performance Max quietly taking credit for sales your Search campaign would have won anyway. People who already know your business search for it by name. Those searches are cheap and convert well, and if Performance Max absorbs them, your overall results look better than they are while your money goes to the wrong place.
Google's own documentation says a Search campaign with an exact match keyword is prioritised over Performance Max when a query hits that keyword, which gives you one safeguard. Google has also added brand exclusions, which stop a Performance Max campaign serving for queries that contain brands you want to keep out. For Performance Max they apply to Search and Shopping inventory. Google's guidance is to use brand settings only on campaigns that really need them, so you do not limit conversion opportunities you actually want.
A simple test: open the search terms and brand impression share reports and see how much of your Performance Max traffic is branded. If it is large, tighten the structure before you scale it.
Stay Ahead of the Curve
Practical digital marketing insights for marketers and business owners, no fluff, straight to your inbox.
Which Should You Start With?
Use your business model and your data volume to decide. This is how we think about it for South African accounts:
| Your situation | Where to start |
|---|---|
| Service business selling by quote (plumber, attorney, installer) | Search first. Add Performance Max only once lead tracking is solid |
| Only a handful of conversions a month | Search. Automation needs enough conversions to learn from |
| E-commerce with a clean product feed | Shopping or Performance Max, with Search running alongside |
| Strong brand, lots of branded searches | Search for brand defence, plus brand exclusions on Performance Max |
| Search is capped by demand and you want to grow | Test Performance Max for new reach, with a clear budget limit |
| No reliable conversion tracking | Neither. Fix tracking first |
Lead generation businesses deserve a special warning. Performance Max optimises toward whatever you tell it counts as a conversion. If that includes low-quality form fills or accidental calls, it will find you more of them. Define conversions around real enquiries, ideally with a quality signal, before you hand the controls to automation. Our guide to clicks without conversions explains why this goes wrong.
Before You Launch: Six Checks
-
Accurate conversion tracking. Test every conversion action. Duplicate or junk conversions will mislead the algorithm. See our GA4 and conversion tracking guide.
-
Conversion values that mean something. If you sell products or have different job sizes, feed real values so the system chases revenue, not volume.
-
A branded Search campaign already running. Then add brand exclusions to Performance Max, so each campaign has a clear role.
-
Strong creative assets. Performance Max mixes your images, video, headlines and descriptions. Weak assets produce weak ads at scale.
-
Audience signals from your own data. Customer lists and website visitors give the system a starting point. They guide it, they do not restrict it.
-
A fair way to judge it. Performance Max reports little by channel, so compare blended account results (total leads or revenue at total cost) before and after, not the campaign's own numbers in isolation.
Same Budget, Better Structure
In our cost-per-lead case study, a plumbing contractor kept the same R12,400 monthly budget and went from 28 leads to 87 by rebuilding a messy account (one broad campaign, mixed match types, an almost empty negative keyword list) and its landing page. The lesson is the same here: how an account is structured usually matters more than which new feature you switch on.
The Short Version
Build your Search foundation first: brand, high-intent services and clean tracking. Add Performance Max when you have the conversion data, the creative and a clear reason: more reach, a product feed to scale, or demand you cannot capture by keyword alone. Keep the two apart with brand exclusions, give each a defined budget, and judge them together. If you want help working out which structure fits your business, our Google Ads team will happily review your account.
Get the Next Playbook First
Practical digital marketing insights for marketers and business owners, no fluff, straight to your inbox.
Sources
Google Ads Help: About brand settings for Search and Performance Max and Apply brand exclusions to Performance Max or Search campaigns. Search and Performance Max priority and the complement-Search guidance, as quoted from Google's documentation: Jetfuel Agency. Channels Performance Max can serve across: TrueFuture Media. Diagnosing branded cannibalisation: Webtonic. Google changes these features often, so check your own account's current options.